UPDATED VERSION: Examining the Incessant Flow of Qatari Money into American Academia: Unintended Consequences on Campus

UPDATED VERSION: Examining the Incessant Flow of Qatari Money into American Academia: Unintended Consequences on Campus

Edited by: Fern Sidman

Until recently, the issue of foreign donations influencing American academia remained unnoticed. However, a study published in 2022 by the National Association of Academics in the United States sheds light on a significant flow of Qatari money to universities in the country, particularly in the aftermath of the September 11 attacks. According to an in depth report that appeared on the Calcalistech.com web site in October 2023,the study reveals that between 2001 and 2021, Qatar donated a staggering $4.7 billion to American universities, making it the largest foreign donor during this period. What initially seemed like harmless financial support has sparked a series of events, raising concerns about the influence on academic institutions.

Qatar, the country that financed ISIS and where Hamas leaders are hiding, is the top donor to American universities. It all makes sense now. pic.twitter.com/pIegPi3Urp

— Dr. Maalouf ‏ (@realMaalouf) May 1, 2024

The study highlights that a considerable portion of the funds received by American universities from Qatar went unreported, violating legal requirements, according to the Calcalisteceh.com report.  This revelation adds a layer of complexity to the already controversial issue. The Qatari financial support, ostensibly meant to foster academic growth, has now come under scrutiny for potential undisclosed motives.

The turning point came after the Hamas attacks on October 7, unleashing an explosion of vehemently anti-Israel propaganda that was regularly broadcast by pro-Hamas student protesters.  The serene atmosphere of academic institutions transformed into a battleground, with vile anti-Semitic sentiments taking center stage.

In October alone, countless campus protests erupted. Calcalistech.com reported that at Amherst University, anti-Israel students staged a riot that led to the arrest of 57 individuals after they took over the administration building. At Tulane University clashes erupted between Jewish students and a pro-Hamas group, escalating when the latter burned the Israeli flag during a demonstration.

Billions of dollars have been poured into American Universities by Qatar with the intended goal of undermining American democracy and values. This is how: pic.twitter.com/y1dRuPGeR6

— Brooke Goldstein (@GoldsteinBrooke) December 7, 2023

At Cooper Union in New York City, Jewish students found themselves locked in the library for safety as pro-Hamas protesters violently confronted them. The report on the Calcalistech.com web site also said that at George Washington University, anti-Semitic messages projected on the library wall intensified concerns, with sentiments like “Free Palestine from the river to the sea” and “Glory to our martyrs.”

In the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas attacks that claimed the lives of 1200 Israelis and others, Jewish and Israeli students across the United States expressed genuine fears for their safety, as was noted in the Calcalistech.com report. The culture of anti-Semitic demonstrations, increasingly marked by violence, has created an environment of hostility on campuses that historically championed free speech and critical thinking.

Elite universities have started acknowledging that these events have transcended the boundaries of progressive concepts on campuses. While universities traditionally uphold free speech, the rapid organization and abundant resources available for these demonstrations raise questions about their origins, according to the information provided in the Calcalistech.com report. The situation mirrors recent concerns in London, where large Palestinian-flag-waving demonstrations hinted at organized efforts beyond expressions of free speech.  Elite universities unwittingly find themselves as potential hotbeds of anti-Semitism, challenging their core principles.

American universities reported receiving a cumulative near $6 billion from Qatar from 2001 onwards, w/more amounts reported in later years

Schools w/Qatar branch campuses get the bulk of these funds ($5.7 billion):

Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, Texas A&M, GTown, Northwestern, VCU https://t.co/zEt4KpIo5L pic.twitter.com/ikSy7kh5rI

— Neetu Arnold (@neetu_arnold) May 5, 2024

Qatar’s relationship with groups like the Taliban, Hamas, Iran, and other terrorists has long been a subject of international concern, according to the report on the CounterExtremism.com website.

The Qatari government contends that its engagement with organizations like Hamas is part of an effort to foster peace and provide sanctuary to top Hamas leaders. However, these relations have raised concerns, especially given allegations of financial support to designated terrorist groups that have sworn the destruction of Israel and have in their charter overtly anti-Semitic rhetoric.

The United States has criticized Qatar for its alleged support of global Islamist terror groups, such as Hamas, offering them a safe haven, diplomatic mediation, financial aid, and, in some cases, weapons. Qatar’s connections to these groups have raised concerns, particularly regarding terrorism-financing operations within its borders. CounterExtremism.com reported that several Qatari nationals have been sanctioned by the U.S. government for their ties to ISIS and al-Qaeda financial networks.

Qatar has found itself in a diplomatic tightrope, maintaining close military ties with the United States while facing accusations of supporting terrorist groups such as al-Qaeda and Hamas.

A report by ISGAP, an American body that studies the spread of anti-Semitism and the anti-democratic actions carried out by countries such as Qatar and its terrorist partners, reveals the depth of the moral decay of American universities, which have been bought with Qatari money pic.twitter.com/Bm5xxPMT24

— Joshua L. Zarka (@yzarka) November 21, 2023

Having said this, it should be noted that prominent American universities, including Cornell, Georgetown, Northwestern, and Carnegie Mellon, received substantial funding from Qatar, leading to the establishment of branches in Doha. As was reported in the Calcalistech.com report, Cornell, a member of the Ivy League, opened a medical school with a staggering $1.8 billion donation from Qatar. Georgetown University was also a recipient of Qatar’s largess as they received $750 million for a school of government. Moreover, Northwestern established a journalism school with a $600 million donation from Qatar in 2007.

The significant share of donations comes from the Qatar Foundation, a non-profit organization established by the government in 1995 with the mission to promote education and science in the country, as was indicated in the Calcalistech.com report. While collaborations between nations and educational institutions are not uncommon in the era of globalization, the source and magnitude of Qatari donations raise unique concerns.

American universities operating in Qatar’s “Education City” were compelled to make adjustments, raising questions about academic freedom. Some institutions removed certain liberal books from reading lists, signaling compromises made in the pursuit of financial support. The report on the Calcalistech.com website revealed that cooperation agreements between Northwestern’s journalism school and controversial media outlets like Al Jazeera further highlight the challenges faced in maintaining academic independence.

A 2020 examination by ISGAP (The Institute for the Study of Global Anti-Semitism and Policy) revealed a direct correlation between donations from Qatar and other Persian Gulf countries and the presence of pro-Palestinian groups, notably SJP (Students for Justice in Palestine), on college campuses, according to the information provided in the Calcalistech.com report. These groups, in some instances, organized demonstrations and days of rage immediately following events in the Middle East, reflecting a concerning alignment with external political agendas.

On January 11^th, the New York Post reported that a global map displayed in a New York City public school classroom omits the existence of Israel, instead being replaced by the label “Palestine.”  According to the Post report, the map is part of the Arab Culture Arts program taught by Rita Lahoud, and funded by Qatar Foundation International, the American arm of Qatar Foundation, a nonprofit organization owned by Qatar’s ruling family.

UPDATE:  The following report from June of this year offers details of Qatari funding of Yale University and the rise of campus anti-Semitism.

ISGAP has once again brought to light the troubling issue of undisclosed foreign funding within American higher education institutions. According to a report that appeared in June on the i24News.com web site, in a damning report released , ISGAP focused on Yale University’s non-compliance with U.S. federal reporting laws concerning foreign funds, specifically from Qatar. The report, titled “The Ongoing Failure to Report: Yale University, Qatar, and Undisclosed Foreign Funding, Volume Two,” is the latest installment in ISGAP’s “Follow the Money” project, an initiative aimed at scrutinizing foreign financial influences on U.S. universities since 2012.

The report’s findings are alarming. According to ISGAP, Yale University reported receiving only $284,668 from Qatar between 2012 and 2023. However, the actual amount is estimated to be a staggering $15,925,711. As was reported by i24News.com, this discrepancy suggests that Yale has failed to comply with Section 117 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA), which requires all U.S. institutions of higher education to report gifts and contracts from foreign sources that exceed $250,000 semi-annually.

It’s like we have all feared…

A new report from @ncri_io shows that the Wahhabi state of Qatar has been pumping billions of dollars into American universities.

The reports shows it has become much more difficult to track the money in recent years.

Full report in the comments pic.twitter.com/17V27zGOnC

— Visegrád 24 (@visegrad24) December 20, 2023

This is not the first time that Yale has been implicated in such practices. Volume One of the ISGAP report, released in 2023, had already unveiled similar non-disclosure practices across several institutions, including Yale. The report on the i24News.com web site said that these revelations led to federal investigations in 2019, shining a spotlight on the university’s financial reporting practices and raising broader questions about transparency and accountability in the realm of higher education.

The report suggests that Qatar’s financial contributions to U.S. institutions, including Yale, are part of a larger strategy to exert influence and promote the interests of the Qatari regime. As per the information provided in the i24News.com report, this influence is reportedly exerted through a series of undisclosed transactions, collaborations, and agreements that fail to appear in Yale’s financial statements or the U.S. Department of Education’s reporting system.

These transactions, which include Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs) and other forms of agreements with Qatari foundations and government agencies, point to a deliberate attempt to keep these financial ties out of public view. The report indicated that ISGAP’s findings highlight how this lack of transparency not only undermines federal reporting requirements but also raises serious concerns about the integrity of higher education institutions that may be unwittingly—or perhaps deliberately—facilitating foreign influence.

Indicated in the i24News.com report was that Dr. Charles Asher Small, Executive Director of ISGAP, emphasized the gravity of these findings back in June. He stated, “The persistent non-disclosure of substantial foreign funds, as well as contracts, MOUs, and agreements with foreign foundations and government agencies, not only undermines transparency and accountability but also poses significant risks to the integrity of higher education.”

Small also pointedly remarked, “The omission of substantial Qatari grants in Yale University’s financial statements raises questions about academic integrity and foreign influence.” His statement reflects a growing concern that foreign funds, when not properly disclosed, may come with strings attached, influencing not only academic curricula and research agendas but also the broader campus environment.

The ISGAP report calls for immediate action to address these issues, including stricter enforcement of existing reporting laws and greater oversight of foreign funding in U.S. universities, as was noted in the i24News.com report.  The findings also suggest the need for a broader public debate on the role of foreign money in higher education and the potential implications for academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and national security.

The i24News report said that this is particularly concerning given the recent sharp increase in anti-Semitism at Yale following the October 7 attacks in Israel. According to ISGAP, universities that receive significant financial support from Qatar have seen higher rates of anti-Semitic incidents, suggesting a troubling correlation between foreign influence and campus climate.

The connection between undisclosed foreign funds and anti-Semitism on campus is not merely speculative. As per the information contained in the i24News report, ISGAP’s research has shown that the influx of foreign money, particularly from regimes known for their controversial stances on human rights and international relations, can create an environment where certain ideologies, including anti-Semitism, may flourish. This situation underscores the need for greater scrutiny and transparency in how universities handle foreign donations.

COMMON KNOWLEDGE:
Since 1986, US ACADEMIA has been the recipient of BILLION$$$ in funding by the richest ARAB NATIONS.
QATARI money pours into American Colleges & Universities, News Media & Govt official’s pockets undetected & unreported!!!
IDENTIFY THE ENEMY not the HYPE. pic.twitter.com/bLHwNszjS4

— Yiskah Chaya (@YiskahZ) April 23, 2024

Additionally, ISGAP advocates for increased scrutiny of foreign donations, particularly from countries with records of human rights abuses or known involvement in promoting extremist ideologies. The report suggests that universities should be required to disclose not only the amount of foreign funding they receive but also the specific purposes for which these funds are intended. This would help to identify any potential conflicts of interest or attempts to influence academic programs and policies.

Finally, the report emphasizes the need for measures to protect academic freedom and institutional autonomy from foreign influence. This includes safeguarding curricula, research agendas, and campus discourse from being shaped by external actors with potentially harmful agendas. By implementing these recommendations, ISGAP hopes to create a more transparent and accountable higher education system that upholds the values of academic integrity and freedom.